You are a nurse. You love your job; the love, the caring, the responsibility, the autonomy, the time to get to know your patients and to work to make them feel better and if everything goes well, the chance to see them go home and live healthy and happy lives. Many times you may have helped them through a harrowing and life-threatening experience, maybe you were able to help bring them back from the brink of death, or maybe, just maybe you were able to make their passage into the next life a peaceful and respected journey. Everyday you work, you help patients, families and doctors, and also your co-workers and managers; and everyday you come in you deal with their expectations and frustrations.
As nurses, we have been taught to be care-givers, listeners, organizers, nurturers, decision-makers, and to be so many other ideals. It is part of being a nurse to give care and consideration to the many people we are consistently responsible to and for, the kind of care they expect and have a right to.
The nursing shortage and recent staffing ratios instituted by many facilities has made giving the right kind of care next to impossible. There is no longer time for all we have to do, more often than not; we are leaving patients in unsafe situations.
This article compares various researchers and their findings on the effects of nurse staffing and the outcomes, difficulties and dangers patients have faced and still face today. “The parallel is astounding. In the late 1990s, modern nursing was under attack from the consulting firms that promoted radically ‘restructured’ care modalities to reduce the costs of patient care. For example, Byron Erwin, President of the APM Consulting Firm, insisted that there should be no nurse above the level of head nurse in any facility (Erwin, 1994)” Curtin (2003). Florence Nightingale was similarly persecuted by Parliament when they tried to blame her for the increase in deaths at Scutari hospital; she was able to exonerate herself by proving the unsanitary conditions in the hospital caused the deaths, Curtin (2003 pg.1). “…Seago (1999) demonstrated that utilizing lower paid nursing assistants to give care actually increased costs. Sovie and Jawad (2001) studied 28 university hospitals that had undergone restructuring and reengineering and found that patient falls increased as nurse/patient ratios increased, while patient satisfaction with pain control decreased as nurse/patient ratios increased” Curtin (2003 pg. 2). In the last five years several studies have been done and they have clearly indicated that there are more patient complications and poor outcomes when nurses are staffed with increasing patient numbers, especially in intensive care units with 1:3 or 1:4 nurse-patient ratios. In another study that included financial risk, these ratios have also been shown to increase hospital costs.
“Dimick and colleagues linked hospital discharge data to a prospective survey of organizational characteristics in the intensive care unit-an indicator that some environments are predictably therapeutic, while others are just as predictably toxic” Curtin (2003 pg. 3). Part of being therapeutic means having nurses with greater autonomy, more nurse control of the unit budgets and resources, and positive communication and collaboration with doctors and the rest of the team providing care for the patients. Studies show that therapeutic environments encourage patient outcomes and toxic ones slow the healing process and increase mortality. “…A higher proportion of hours of care provided by registered nurses was also was associated with lower rates of pneumonia, shock or cardiac arrest, and ‘failure to rescue,’ which was defined as death from pneumonia, shock or cardiac arrest, upper gastrointestinal bleeding, sepsis, or deep vein thrombosis” Curtin (2003 pg. 5). Study after study shows that a higher nurse/patient ratio (i.e. 1:2 in ICU and 1:4-6 on the floor) significantly reduces the risk to patients and the adverse affects of their stay. “Results demonstrated that the odds of patient mortality increased by 7 percent for every additional patient (over 4) in the average nurses workload. The same increase in odds was evident with respect to the failure to rescue rate” Curtin (2003 pg. 6).
Several other studies found that staffing and nurse turnover are heavily related to the outcomes, length of stay, and increased hospital costs. Institutions that provide better ratios have less nurse turnover and experience less undesirable patient outcomes/sentinel events, thereby decreasing hospital costs. Just the costs of orienting new nurses would decrease with fewer turnovers.
Nurses’ education has also proven to affect the number of poor patient outcomes. “A 10 percent increase in the proportion of RN’s across all hospital types was associated with five fewer deaths for every 1000 discharged patients” Curtin (2003 pg. 7). Another study showed that “A 10 percent increase in the proportion of nurses holding a bachelor’s degree was associated with a 5 percent decrease in both the likelihood of patients dying within 30 days of admission and the odds of failure to rescue” Curtin (2003 pg. 7).
“Only nurses can nurse, but administrators create the environment and circumstances within which care is given. If the environment is toxic, nurses will leave, patients will suffer, and in the end, hospitals will lose the money they are trying to save” Curtin (2003 pg. 8).
In conclusion, many nurses feel that most administrations care more about the bottom line than the nurses, and therefore, the patients’ well-being. This would be a result of the non-nursing administrators operating the institutions around this country. With better staffing ratios, patients will receive the care they expect and deserve. Nurses will be able to, if not prevent, at least delay sentinel events, leading to improved patient outcomes. Increasing nurse/patient ratios, encouraging autonomy and allowing nurses more control of their environment and responsibility of its operation will decrease nurse turnovers. It will make them more concerned in maintaining good relationships with doctors and various other co-workers involved in the patients care. With such autonomy and accountability, more nurses will seek higher levels of education and professionalism, and the result will be better patient outcomes, lower hospital costs, and a decrease in continuing nurse shortages.
References
Curtin, L. L. (2003, September 30). An integrated analysis of nurse staffing and related variables: effects on patient outcomes. Retrieved May 8, 2005, from Online Journal of Issues in Nursing Web Site: http://www.ana.org/ojin/topic22/tpc22_5.htm